Formal Syntax Parsing Issues in Lynx CSS Documentation

[Dugyu]

Summary

While parsing Formal Syntax strings extracted from Lynx's official CSS property documentation using css-tree's definitionSyntax.parse(), we encountered several failure cases due to either grammar violations or parser limitations (especially when using spec-like notation). This issue documents the exact syntax strings, errors thrown, and their associated propertyName.

Parsing Failures

1. Quantifier on Bracketed Expressions

[<length>]{3}

Property: -x-auto-font-size-preset-sizes

Error:

Unexpected input

Cause: css-tree disallows applying {} quantifiers directly to bracketed expressions.

Fix:

(<length>){3}

---

2. Quantified Optional Alternatives

true [<length>]{0,3} | false

Property: -x-auto-font-size

Error:

Unexpected input

Fix:

true (<length>){0,3} | false

---

3. Spec-style where Clauses for Type Definitions

<bg-image> = none | <image> where <image> = <url> | <gradient>

Property: background-image

Error:

Unexpected input

Cause: definitionSyntax.parse() does not support where clauses or inline type aliasing.

Recommendation: Inline type definitions should be separated or pre-registered as custom types.

---

4. Whitespace Inside Angle-Bracketed Types

<mask-reference >#

Property: mask-image

Error:

Expect `>`

Besides removing the whitespace, we should flatten the nested <image> and <url()> block:

Fix:

mask-image = 
  <mask-reference>#  

<mask-reference> = 
  none       |
  <image>    

<image> = 
  <url()>    |
  <gradient>  

<url()> = 
  url( <string> )

---

5. Whitespace in Named Type Repetition

<mask-layer >#

Property: mask

Error:

Expect `>`

Fix:

mask = 
  <mask-layer>#  

<mask-layer> = 
  <mask-reference>               ||
  <position> [ / <bg-size> ]?    ||
  <repeat-style>                 ||
  <box>                          ||
  <compositing-operator>         ||
  <masking-mode>                

<mask-reference> = 
  none       |
  <image>    

<image> = 
  <url()>   |
  <gradient>  

<url()> = 
  url( <string> )

<position> = 
  [ left | center | right ] && [ top | center | bottom ]            |
  [ left | center | right | <length-percentage> ] 
    [ top | center | bottom | <length-percentage> ]?                |
  [ [ left | right ] <length-percentage> ] &&
    [ [ top | bottom ] <length-percentage> ]  

<bg-size> = 
  [ <length-percentage> | auto ]{1,2}  |
  cover                                |
  contain                              

<repeat-style> = 
  repeat-x                             |
  repeat-y                             |
  [ repeat | space | round | no-repeat ]{1,2}  

<box> = 
  border-box     |
  padding-box    |
  content-box    

<compositing-operator> = 
  add        |
  subtract   |
  intersect  |
  exclude    

<masking-mode> = 
  alpha         |
  luminance     |
  match-source  

<length-percentage> = 
  <length>      |
  <percentage>  

---

6. Quantifier on Bracketed Alternates

<bg-size> = [ <length-percentage> | auto ] {1, 2} | cover | contain

Property: background-size

Error:

Unexpected input

Fix:

<bg-size> = (<length-percentage> | auto){1,2} | cover | contain

background-image = <bg-image>#

<bg-image> = none | <image>

<image> = <url()> | <gradient>

<url()> = url(<string>)

<gradient> = <linear-gradient()> | <radial-gradient()>

<linear-gradient()> = 
  linear-gradient( [ <angle> | to <side-or-corner> ]? , <color-stop-list> )

<radial-gradient()> = 
  radial-gradient( [ <ending-shape> || <size> ]? [ at <position> ]? , <color-stop-list> )

<side-or-corner> = 
  [ left | right ] || [ top | bottom ]

<ending-shape> = 
  circle | ellipse

<size> = 
  closest-side       |
  farthest-side      |
  closest-corner     |
  farthest-corner    |
  <length>           |
  <length-percentage>{2}

<position> = 
  [ left | center | right ] || [ top | center | bottom ]                            |
  [ left | center | right | <length-percentage> ] 
    [ top | center | bottom | <length-percentage> ]?                                |
  [ [ left | right ] <length-percentage> ] &&
    [ [ top | bottom ] <length-percentage> ]

<color-stop-list> = <linear-color-stop> ( ',' <linear-color-stop> )*

<linear-color-stop> = <color>

<length-percentage> = <length> | <percentage>

---

7. Inline Spec Dump (Too Large for One Parse)

<mask-layer> = <mask-reference> || <position> [ / <bg-size> ]? ...

Property: mask

Error:

Expect `>`

Cause: Multiple deeply nested inline type definitions, invalid angle brackets, and unbalanced <...>.

Fix: Split into smaller, composable type definitions or validate manually.

---

8. Non-standard Formal Syntax Definitions

The following properties either:

• Are missing ## Formal Syntax sections
• Contain inline prose with no parseable structure
• Use semicolon-separated syntax examples (e.g. sample values)

Property Name	Problem
clip-path	No formal syntax section
css-variable	No formal syntax section
order	No formal syntax section
position	No formal syntax section
relative-center	No formal syntax section
relative-id	No formal syntax section
row-gap	Literal value examples, not grammar

Example for row-gap:

20px; row-gap: 1em; row-gap: 10%; row-gap: calc(10% + 20px)

Error:

Unexpected input

Fix:

row-gap = <length-percentage [0,∞]>

<length-percentage> = <length> | <percentage>

---

Context

We are building a static extractor that parses Formal Syntax strings from docs/en/api/css/properties/*.mdx, then uses css-tree to validate and eventually convert them into a typed schema to be used in @lynx-js/css-defines.

---

Suggestions

Would it be feasible to:

• Improve error reporting for these edge cases?
• Add support for more spec-style constructs (where, relaxed angle brackets)?
• Provide a tolerant mode or pre-validator to assist consumers working with documentation-based sources?

We’re happy to contribute fixtures, test cases, or parsing strategies if this is useful.

---